An introduction to electronic signatures
Electronic signatures have been used successfully for many years, both in the Federal Administration and in the private sector. They enable or facilitate the fully digital exchange of documents; depending on the type of electronic signature, they can replace a handwritten signature; they can confirm, in accordance with the law, the authenticity and origin of documents as well as the identity of the signatory; and they serve to ensure the legally compliant archiving of electronic documents or, in the event of a dispute, can be used as evidence subject to the rule that the court is free to assess evidence as it sees fit.
Electronic signatures are used, for example, when signing contracts, issuing administrative decisions, submitting electronic applications to public authorities, drawing up notarial deeds, or obtaining digital extracts from debt enforcement or criminal records registers.
In theory, electronically signed documents can be checked to determine whether they have been altered since they were signed (integrity), when the electronic signature was applied, and who created it (authenticity). These possibilities give electronically signed documents a clear advantage over traditional paper-based signatures, particularly in terms of security, evidential value and efficiency.
However, not all electronic signatures are the same. In practice, electronic signatures have various types and levels of quality, and not every electronic signature possesses the characteristics mentioned or is suitable for the purposes described. With the Federal Act on Electronic Signatures (ESigA, SR 943.03), the Swiss legislature has established a trust infrastructure and defined within it certain types of electronic signatures which must meet specific requirements and may only be created by recognised certification service providers. These include the ‘qualified electronic signature’ (QES), the ‘regulated electronic seal’ and the ‘qualified electronic timestamp’.
These electronic signatures are therefore considered to be highly reliable, and are the only electronic signatures that have legally binding effects that are expressly regulated by the law. The Federal Administration also provides a validator that can be used to verify these regulated electronic signatures in particular, in a simple, comprehensive and legally secure manner.
Before deciding to use a type of electronic signature that is not governed by the ESigA, it is advisable to carefully consider its properties and legal implications. An electronic signature that is supposedly cost-effective but of limited quality, and which can only be verified by the Validator to a limited extent or not at all, may prove to be disadvantageous or more costly in the long run, for example if legal proof of the signatory’s identity (authenticity) or the unaltered nature of a document (integrity) is required at a later date. In this connection, it is also important to consider the time frame within which this proof is to be provided: if it is to remain reliable even after eleven years, the concept of long-term validation (LTV) must be applied during the signing process.
The following pages provide a concise overview of the key decision-making criteria relating to the use of electronic signatures. They explain the key points to bear in mind and provide practical guidance on how to create an electronic signature or verify the electronic signature of a received document.